Overeating A Sign Of Early Mental Health Problems Among Preschooler Girls

Key Takeaways

• Preschoolers who regularly eat too much are showing signs of early emotional problems

• Girls who overate at a young age were more likely to develop anxiety, impulsivity and hyperactivity as teenagers

• The same association was not found with boys, and picky eaters had no higher risk of mental health problems

MONDAY, Oct. 6, 2025 (HealthDay News) — Preschoolers who regularly overeat are likely swallowing their emotions as well, a new study says.

Girls who overeat as preschoolers are more likely to develop anxiety, impulsivity and hyperactivity when they grow into teenagers, researchers reported in the journal BMC Pediatrics.

The results indicate that children’s eating patterns could be early signs of mental health challenges, researchers said.

“Occasional overeating is normal, but if a child frequently overeats, it can be a sign of emotional struggles,” senior researcher Linda Booij, a professor of psychiatry at McGill University in Quebec, Canada, said in a news release.

For the new study, researchers followed more than 2,000 Quebec children from early childhood through age 15.

Researchers found three patterns of overeating in preschoolers: 60% never overate; 14% started overeating between 2 and 4 years of age; and 26% overate starting around age 4.

Girls, but not boys, who started overeating at a young age were more likely than those who weren't overeaters to report anxiety, hyperactivity and impulsivity by age 15, results show.

“It could be that parents may sometimes monitor girls’ eating more closely than boys’, and restrictive environments could be linked to increased risk of disordered eating later in life,” Booij said. “The social context around girls’ eating habits may partly explain why overeating is linked with later difficulties for them.”

More from this section

Two Of Five Drivers Killed In Car Crashes Were Stoned, Study Says

Whooping Cough Cases on the Rise: Newborns Most at Risk, Experts Say

Air Pollution Particles Hitch A Ride On Red Blood Cells, Into Major Organs, Study Says

In fact, dietary restriction is not the answer for helping these potentially troubled young girls, Booij said.

“Strict control can make things worse and even increase the risk of disordered eating,” Booij said. “Instead, parents and caregivers should also pay attention to children’s emotional well-being.”

The researchers also looked at picky eating, but found no connection with later mental health problems as a teenager.

While many parents worry about picky eating, it’s often a common developmental phase that doesn’t necessarily signal later mental or emotional problems, Booij said.

However, if picky eating persists over time, it might become a cause for concern, particularly if it interferes with a child’s growth, nutrition or daily functioning, Booij said.

More information

Nationwide Children’s Hospital has more on compulsive overeating.

SOURCE: McGill University, news release, Sept. 29, 2025

What This Means For You

Parents of preschoolers who compulsively overeat should look into their child’s emotional well-being, rather than try to restrict their diet.