Study suggests physical labor may raise dementia risk

By Stephen Beech

Physical activity performed as part of a job raises the risk of dementia, suggests new research.

Physically strenuous labor may not offer the same brain protection as exercising for leisure — and may even raise the risk of developing the debilitating condition, say scientists.

But leisure-time exercise — such as walking, cycling, running, swimming or playing sports — "substantially" lowers the risk of dementia, according to the multinational study.

Research has previously shown that regular physical activity can help lower the chances of dementia.

However, the new analysis of previous studies involving more than 4.2 million people suggests that it's not only the amount of exercise, but also the activity's context — for work or for leisure — that makes a difference.

The findings, published in The Lancet Public Health, are the first to systematically examine whether the so-called "physical activity paradox" extends to dementia.

The paradox, well documented in cardiovascular research, describes the surprising observation that physically demanding jobs don't provide the same health benefits as voluntary exercise — and may even increase the risk of disease.

The team analyzed data from 74 studies involving more than 4.2 million participants, aged 45 to 93, across 30 countries.

Participants were followed for an average of 10 years, during which researchers tracked diagnoses of all-cause dementia, Alzheimer's disease and vascular dementia.

Overall, people who engaged in higher levels of leisure-time physical activity had a 24% lower risk of dementia than those who were least active.

Household physical activity also appeared beneficial, although evidence came from only a single study.

By contrast, occupational physical activity was associated with a 20% higher dementia risk, while active commuting showed a "modest" increase in risk, although those findings were based on just two studies.

Study first author Natan Feter, from the University of Southern California (USC), said: "The findings challenge the long-held assumption that 'every move counts' for brain health."

He explained that "physical activity" statistics often combines exercise, manual labor, housework and commuting into a single measure.

More from this section

Study suggests physical labor may raise dementia risk

What happens when your hospital is also your insurance company? We’re starting to see the effects

US teens are smoking and vaping less than their peers abroad

But the researchers pointed out that the different forms of activity occur under "very different" circumstances and may have distinct effects on long-term health.

Feter said leisure-time exercise is usually self-directed, can be performed at an enjoyable intensity and is often accompanied by social interaction or stress reduction.

But physically demanding jobs may involve repetitive tasks, prolonged standing, heavy lifting, limited recovery time and exposure to workplace hazards.

The research team said that the apparent harms associated with occupational activity are unlikely to be caused by movement itself.

Instead, they may reflect the broader social and environmental conditions that often accompany physically demanding work.

Manual occupations are also more likely to involve stress, lower job control, hazardous working conditions and greater exposure to air and noise pollution, all factors that have independently been linked to dementia risk.

Feter said: "Workers in those jobs may also have fewer opportunities for recreational exercise because of time constraints, fatigue or limited access to safe places for physical activity."

The findings showed that leisure-time exercise and occupational physical activity exhibited contrasting associations with dementia risk.

Higher levels of leisure-time exercise were associated with progressively lower dementia risk until the association plateaued, whereas higher levels of occupational physical activity were associated with progressively greater dementia risk before also plateauing.

The researchers noted that evidence remains sparse for household and commuting activity, preventing firm conclusions about those domains.

They also said that most of the available research came from high-income countries, even though low- and middle-income countries are expected to experience the largest increases in dementia cases in future years.

But Feter says that the "consistency" of the results across multiple sensitivity analyses gives confidence that the association should be taken seriously.

The research team cautioned that the results do not mean people should avoid physically active jobs.

Instead, rather than simply encouraging people to "move more," they said dementia prevention efforts should recognize that not all physical activity occurs under the same conditions.

Research leader David Raichlen, from USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences, said: "In other words, when it comes to protecting the brain, the context of physical activity may matter just as much as movement itself."

He added: "Improving access to safe parks, walking trails and recreational facilities, ensuring people have adequate leisure time for exercise, and reducing harmful workplace exposures may ultimately prove as important as promoting physical activity itself."