thinker_featured
vitaly-gariev-7npZTGLxACA-unsplash

Vitaly Gariev

AI is changing Americans’ minds: Nearly half of users (44%) say it has changed a decision they were planning to make.

But are they making better decisions or just different ones?

The findings emerged in a survey of 2,000 Americans who have used an AI tool or assistant for a personal task in the last three months, according to the data from We are Talker.

Results showed 44% of users feel information or recommendations from AI have caused them to change their mind about a decision.

When asked for details on instances of AI changing their mind, one respondent said it changed their perception about whether they could afford to return to college or not. Another was convinced to challenge a parking ticket they’d previously decided to pay while one person said it convinced them to buy a used car over buying new.

Two in three (65%) AI users deliberately ask it to challenge their thinking.

pexels-george-milton-7034445

(Photo by George Milton via Pexels)

Younger users are far more likely to use AI for the purpose of deliberately challenging their thinking, with 89% of Gen Z and 84% of millennials doing so, dropping to 67% for Gen X and just 34% of boomers.

The results showed younger users, especially, are interacting far beyond a “question-answer” dynamic. 54% of all users often or always ask follow-up questions instead of taking the first answer, jumping to 72% of Gen Z.

One in three (33%) uses AI as one of several research tools when making decisions. An additional 27% say it's the first place they go for information.

A further one in five (21%) said it has helped them rule options out and three-quarters (74%) said AI introduced them to something that ultimately became their final choice.

Leslie Poston, PhD, a media psychologist who studies how technology shapes cognition, identity and decision-making and the founder of the consultancy Mind Media Tech, points to a generational shift.

pexels-cottonbro-8088445

cottonbro studio

“The 89% Gen Z figure is striking,” Poston said, “but it makes sense when you consider that this generation grew up with less access to informal mentorship and more access to information than any generation before them. They have plenty of data, but fewer trusted sounding boards.

“Asking AI to push back fills a gap that used to be filled by extended family, workplace mentors, or community. It also feels psychologically safer to ask a machine to tell you why you're wrong; there's no social cost like judgment, damaged relationships, or power dynamics.”

Poston sees both promise and caution in how Americans are interacting with AI: “The statistic that 54% are asking follow-up questions rather than flat-out accepting the first answer is encouraging,” Poston said. “That indicates critical thinking behavior, and not a default to passive consumption. The risk shows up in that 44% figure, where AI actually changed a decision someone was planning to make. The question remains whether those were better decisions or just different ones.”

So what should people watch for when they turn to AI for a second opinion? Poston suggests paying attention to how they’re asking, not just what the answer is.

“If you find yourself asking AI the same question multiple times until it gives you the answer you wanted, that’s a sign you’ve already made your decision and you’re looking for permission, not perspective,” she said.

pexels-george-milton-6953927 (1)

(Photo by George Milton via Pexels)

Among those who said AI changed a decision, shopping and retail topped the list (27%), followed by food (24%), health (24%) and financial decisions (22%).

As a result of using AI, 24% said they considered options they hadn't previously known about, while an additional 22% reported AI helped them confirm their original choice

Tim Haslam, CEO of We are Talker, said: “What stood out to us is that people aren’t using AI to be told what to do. Two in three are asking it to push back and nearly half say it has changed a decision they’d already made.

“AI has become a real voice in everyday choices, from what to buy to whether to fight a ticket. For brands, that means the conversation that shapes a decision is increasingly one they aren’t in and what AI says about them depends on what’s been credibly published about them.”

pexels-tim-witzdam-1081250691-32021560 (1)

(Photo by Tim Witzdam via Pexels)

  • “I didn’t want to go to the emergency room. AI convinced me to go.”
  • “When I got a ticket, and I was going to pay it, I asked AI what I should do, and AI recommended that I fight it.”
  • “I was going to buy a new Dodge Charger. AI talked me into a used [one] instead. I’m happy it did.”
  • “I was interested in investing in a particular set of ETFs, but… I realized I would be setting myself up for a large tax charge in the future. So I selected a different set.”
  • “That I can afford to return to college.” (On deciding whether or not to go back to school)
  • “When I asked about putting my heart back out there. My ex wanted to get back together. I used pro/con questions.”
  • “Wanted to try a new vitamin, but AI let me know that because of some health issues I have, it wouldn’t be a good idea.”

Research methodology:

Talker Research surveyed 2,000 Americans who have used an AI tool or assistant for a personal/non-work related purpose within the last three months who also have access to the internet; the survey was commissioned by We are Talker and administered and conducted online by Talker Research between Sept. 21–30, 2026. A link to the questionnaire can be found here.

To view the complete methodology as part of AAPOR’s Transparency Initiative, please visit the Talker Research Process and Methodology page.

Originally published on talker.news, part of the BLOX Digital Content Exchange.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.