Mental health inequities at work are costing employers more than they might realize

Mental health inequities at work are costing employers more than they might realize

For employers seeing low mental health utilization, rising burnout, and steadily increasing healthcare costs, the problem may not be awareness.

It may be mental health equity.

Spring Health recently completed a large, peer-reviewed U.S. study of more than 740,000 people and found that more modern, enhanced mental health solutions can drive higher use, better outcomes, and more equitable access across socioeconomic groups than traditional health plans.

However, when mental health support isn’t designed equitably, organizations quietly pay what is called the status quo tax: a rising healthcare trend without meaningful improvement in outcomes.

Read on for a breakdown of what mental health equity actually means and how to operationalize it.

What is mental health equity?

According to the CDC, health equity is “the state in which everyone has a fair and just opportunity to attain their highest level of health.”

In the workplace, mental health equity means:

• Employees can access care quickly, regardless of geography or income.
• Providers reflect diverse identities and lived experiences.
• Care plans are personalized, not one-size-fits-all.
• Outcomes are consistent across race, gender, income, and role.

Equality gives everyone the same benefits.

Equity ensures everyone can use and benefit from that support.

That distinction has direct financial implications.

When certain populations can’t access effective care, mental health conditions go untreated. Untreated mental health conditions are strongly correlated with:

• Increased ER visits
• Higher physical health claims
• Poor chronic disease management
• Higher pharmacy spend
• Increased absenteeism and presenteeism

Mental health equity is not just a cultural imperative. It is a cost-containment lever.

5 mental health equity strategies that improve outcomes and ROI

1. Measure disparities and not just utilization

If a certain percentage of your population uses your EAP, but engagement is more highly concentrated among salaried corporate employees while frontline workers rarely access support, that’s not success.

That’s imbalance.

Spring Health recently surveyed 1,500+ full-time employees who had access to a variety of different mental health solutions, or no solution at all. Two key findings from full-time employees were:

• 75% of managers said they were offered mental health benefits by their employer, while only 49% of non-managers said the same.
• 87% of managers said they had used their employer’s mental health benefits in the past year, while only 41% of non-managers said the same.

These gaps in awareness (nearly every employee at mid-to-large-sized organizations is offered an EAP, according to Mental Health America) and utilization indicate an opportunity to improve mental health equity.

To advance mental health equity in the workplace, organizations can:

• Segment utilization and outcomes by demographic groups.
• Run anonymous surveys with optional identifiers for key demographics.
• Use real-time dashboards to identify engagement gaps.

More from this section

New research suggests tattoos could protect against skin cancer

Are ADHD medications overprescribed in kids?

Do parents who drink influence their kids’ future alcohol habits?

When you uncover disparities early, you prevent downstream costs, like long-term leaves or crisis escalations.

2. Invest in managers as equity multipliers

Managers influence employee mental health as much as spouses or partners do, and more than doctors and therapists do. That’s why it’s important to invest in mental health training for managers.

What would effective training and resources for managers look like? They could include:

• Leadership training on psychological safety
• Manager consultations with mental health experts
• Self-guided resilience tools
• Clear referral pathways

Equipping managers reduces mental health stigma, accelerates early intervention, and reduces higher-cost care later.

3. Replace one-size-fits-all care with precision matching

Traditional EAPs often rely on static provider lists and phone-based intake. That model reinforces inequity. Spring Health’s research revealed that the most common barriers to care for employees are:

• Lack of time
• Cost of care
• Privacy concerns
• Long wait times

The result? Low engagement and delayed care.

Equitable mental health solutions prioritize:

• Diverse provider networks
• Fast access (appointments in days, not weeks)
• Personalized care plans based on validated assessments
• A full spectrum of support (coaching, therapy, medication management, specialty care)

When you remove those barriers, engagement increases meaningfully. And higher-quality engagement is what drives cost offsets in physical health spend.

4. Support caregivers and flexible work policies

Mental health equity extends beyond access to therapy. Caregiving responsibilities, such as childcare, eldercare, and neurodivergent support, disproportionately affect certain employee populations.

When organizations ignore these realities, they could see higher burnout, increased leave requests, reduced productivity, and higher turnover among working parents and caregivers.

Flexible work policies, where operationally possible, are equity accelerators:

• Flexible scheduling
• Remote options
• Meeting-free windows
• Caregiver-specific communication strategies

5. Address social determinants of health

Mental health outcomes are deeply influenced by social determinants of health, which are the conditions in which people live, work, and age.

Financial stress, food insecurity, housing instability, and transportation barriers all affect wellbeing.

Employees with unmet social needs may experience worse health outcomes, higher healthcare costs, and lower productivity.

Mental health equity strategies could include:

• Financial wellness programs
• Student loan support
• Emergency assistance funds
• Retirement planning services
• Flexible paid time off

This story was produced by Spring Health and reviewed and distributed by Stacker.